Oh, MG
Subscribe
Cover photo

The Canadian Soccer Team Argument For Open Borders

In the 1970s and '80s, Canada let in lots of immigrants, many of whom happened to be from countries that care a lot about soccer.

Malcolm Gladwell

Apr 27
10
31

My brother emailed me recently and said I should look at the roster of the Canadian men’s national soccer team, which will head to the World Cup this fall. It was, he said, an argument for Canada’s immigration policy. And so it is. Take a look. I’ve highlighted everyone who was either born somewhere else or whose parents were born somewhere else:

  • Milan Borjan (Red Star Belgrade)

    • Place of birth: Knin, Croatia (then the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia)

    • Moved to Canada in 2000

  • Maxime Crépeau (LAFC)

    • Place of birth: Greenfield Park, Quebec, Canada

  • Dayne St. Clair (Minnesota United FC)

    • Place of birth: Pickering, Ontario, Canada

    • Trinidadian father and Canadian-Scottish mother

  • Samuel Adekugbe (Hatayspor FC)

    • Place of birth: London, England

    • British-Nigerian parents

    • Moved to Canada when he was 10

  • Derek Cornelius (Panetolikos FC)

    • Place of birth: Ajax, Ontario, Canada

    • Barbadian father and Jamaican mother

  • Cristián Gutiérrez (Vancouver Whitecaps FC)

    • Place of birth: Greenfield Park, Quebec, Canada

    • Raised in Chile; parents are Chilean

  • Doneil Henry (LAFC)

    • Place of birth: Brampton, Ontario, Canada

    • Parents moved to Canada from Jamaica

  • Alistair Johnston (CF Montréal)

    • Place of birth: Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

    • Canadian father and Northern Irish mother

  • Scott Kennedy (SSV Jahn Regensburg)

    • Place of birth: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

  • Richie Laryea (Nottingham Forest FC)

    • Place of birth: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

    • Parents from Ghana

  • Kamal Miller (CF Montréal)

    • Place of birth: Scarborough, Ontario, Canada

  • Steven Vitória (Moreirense FC)

    • Place of birth: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

    • Parents are Portuguese immigrants from the Azores

  • Stephen Eustáquio (FC Porto)

    • Place of birth: Leamington, Canada

    • Portuguese parents, moved to Portugal as a kid

  • Liam Fraser (KMSK Deinze)

    • Place of birth: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

  • Atiba Hutchinson (Beşiktaş JK)

    • Place of birth: Brampton, Ontario, Canada

    • Trinidadian parents

  • Mark-Anthony Kaye (Colorado Rapids)

    • Place of birth: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

  • Jonathan Osorio (Toronto FC)

    • Place of birth: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

    • Parents are Colombian

  • Ismaël Koné (CF Montréal)

    • Place of birth: Abidjan, Ivory Coast

    • Moved to Montreal as a kid

  • Tajon Buchanan (Club Brugge KV)

    • Place of birth: Brampton, Ontario, Canada

  • Lucas Cavallini (Vancouver Whitecaps FC)

    • Place of birth: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

    • Argentinian father and Canadian mother

  • Jonathan David (Lille OSC)

    • Place of birth: Brooklyn, New York, United States

    • Born in New York City to Haitian parents; grew up in Haiti and Ottawa

  • David Junior Hoilett (Reading FC)

    • Place of birth: Brampton, Ontario, Canada

    • Jamaican parents

  • Cyle Larin (Beşiktaş JK)

    • Place of birth: Brampton, Ontario, Canada

    • Jamaican father, Jamaican-Canadian mother

  • Liam Millar (FC Basel)

    • Place of birth: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

  • Iké Ugbo (KRC Genk)

    • Place of birth: Lewisham, England

    • Parents are Nigerian; moved to Canada from England when he was 4

I mean, this is ridiculous. There are maybe six players whose families have been in Canada more than one generation. I say “maybe,” because it was hard to get background information on Kamal Miller and Tajon Buchanan—and I wouldn’t be surprised if either of those players were of, say, West Indian ancestry. So that number could be even lower!

I have to say, this list fills me with delight—and not just because I’m someone who thinks that western countries like Canada and the United States should take lots and lots of immigrants. It’s because this list proves a very simple and powerful point about what immigration does.

Herewith a short primer on the Canadian soccer team theory of open borders.

Canada is not historically a soccer power. Good Canadian athletes play hockey. In 2014, Canada’s soccer team was ranked 122nd in the world, ahead of Guinea-Bissau and behind the Central African Republic. To put it bluntly, we sucked. (Yes, we. Have you forgotten I’m Canadian?) But during the 1970s and 1980s, Canada let in lots of immigrants, many of whom happened to be from countries that care a lot about soccer. Those immigrants made sure that their children played lots of soccer growing up. Those children have now grown up. Some of them turned out to be really good soccer players, and—voila—Canada is now ranked among the top 40 teams in the world. In 2022, Canada will play in the World Cup for only the second time ever.

What’s the lesson? The great fear among many people who are against immigration is that letting in lots of newcomers is a zero-sum game: Immigrants will take jobs and opportunities from existing citizens. But the athletes who make up the suddenly formidable Canadian national team did not choose to play hockey, and take hockey jobs from hardworking farmers’ sons from rural Manitoba. They chose to exploit an opportunity that Canada had—up until that point—neglected.

I have given you one example. But I could easily give you many more. Immigrants tend to do new things. The Jewish immigrants who came from Eastern Europe in the late 19th century did not move to the Midwest and put the fourth-generation dairy farmers of Wisconsin out of business. They brought with them experience in the garment trades. And they used that experience to create what was by the early 20th century one of the most important industries in the United States.

The logic of this is straightforward: if you move somewhere new, where you don’t have any resources or connections to the existing power structure, of course you look to do something that no one else is doing. The anti-immigration fear is based on the notion that immigrants will invade the status quo and chase away the incumbents. But the reality of what immigration usually does is totally different. They don’t colonize the status quo. They change it. They take a land that had never thought about soccer before and turn it into a soccer powerbase.

I suppose there are people who don’t like this kind of change either, who want their country to remain frozen in amber—who want Canada to always be a country about hockey and not a country that is also about soccer. Fine. But we should at least be clear that these two fears—the fear of being replaced and the fear of change—are very different. And the second fear—that immigrants will disorder our existing hierarchy of institutions and preferences—is a lot easier to accommodate than the first fear, which is existential. Over time, I suspect, the hockey-firsters will start watching a few soccer games. And if Canada wins a few games at the World Cup, they might feel a twinge of pride. And before long, when they realize the hockey jobs are safe, they may grudgingly concede that the million new things immigrants have brought to Canada over the past two generations have made our country an infinitely more interesting place.

By the way, what team did Canada soundly defeat in the final round of the World Cup qualifiers in January? The United States! By a score of 2-0, on goals by Sam Adekugbe and Cyle Larin. Check out the roster. Adekugbe was born in England, of Nigerian descent, and Cyle Larin is of Jamaican descent. Actually, I take that back. Don’t check out the roster. Where either of them are from is irrelevant. They are Canadians now.

[Photo: GEOFF ROBINS/AFP via Getty Images]

Subscribe for free to Oh, MG
By subscribing, you agree to share your email address with Malcolm Gladwell to receive their original content, including promotions. Unsubscribe at any time. Meta will also use your information subject to the Bulletin Terms and Policies
Like · 10
Comment · 31
Share

More from Oh, MG
See all

Tucker Carlson Is a Sideshow

It’s entirely possible that Carlson influenced the Buffalo shooter. But we might be overstating the Fox News host’s reach.
May 17
40
64

The Magic of Revisionist History “Table Reads” Is Coming to the Live Stage

This is the first live show of this kind we’ve ever done, and I wanted to explain why we’re doing it.
Apr 30
5
3

Lia Thomas, Trans Rights, and the Future of Elite Sports: 3 Takeaways From My MIT Panel

The male/female categories for sports were invented 100 years ago. Those categories now fit awkwardly at best to the world we live in today.
Apr 12
13
76
Comments
Log in with Facebook to comment

31 Comments

  • Diana Sheprak
    Enjoyed the read. As a first generation Canadian on my dad's side and second on my mom's, I can certainly appreciate Canada's welcoming immigrants. But in their day, no one provided any helping hands. From the moment they stepped foot onto Canadian soi…
    See more
    • 2w
    1 Reply
  • Becky Giberson
    I love this article so much.....both as a Canadian and a "Hockey Mom". With zero soccer knowledge and previously little interest in the sport, my family was glued to the TV cheering on team Canada on their quest to the World Cup. Expanding our sport …
    See more
    • 3w
  • Liane Berry
    This was a super cool read indeed! So exciting about the World Cup and I look forward to watching it all play out. I agree that immigrants help make our country an interesting and culturally diverse place, which is the best thing ever. Hockey is no lon…
    See more
    • 3w
  • Kent James
    While I appreciate (and agree with) the sentiment that immigrants improve societies, and your distinction between immigrants replacing native born and immigrants changing the country is excellent, as an American, I have to object to the characterizatio…
    See more
    • 2w
  • Randy Baker
    The title of the article is more than misleading, it is very disingenuous. If it were an argument for open borders we wouldn't be discussing nations. An accurate title would be 'An Argument for Immigration.' That makes good sense.
    2
    • 3w
  • John Seetoo
    "Open borders" implies a bypassing of a nation's immigration and border security protocols. How many or which of these soccer players entered Canada in that manner? If the answer is zero, then the article makes a case for legal immigration, rather than…
    See more
    • 2w
  • Scott Schwenter
    The USA team makeup is similar though many are European born with one American parent. But the (excellent) arguments made in the article don’t win over conservatives, who hate soccer once their kids stop playing it.
    • 3w
  • Phil Jensen
    Re open borders and soccer, the argument on the surface seems convincing but I have some doubts. To be clear, my father immigrated to Canada from a soccer country, and I have no issues with acceptance of immigrants to our country in general, but using …
    See more
    • 3w
  • Carl Furtado
    Thx Malcolm for the assessment of soccer in canada 55 yrs ago in Galt Ontario no one played soccer at school or organized some old boys had soccer club at the Italian club now gone and Portuguese club still alive but not very active
    • 3w
  • Nick Lapiccirella
    Bravo soccer playing Canadians of many different shades, from many different original countries and who's original mother tongue is neither English or French. We salute what you have accomplished and hopefully this is but the first step that will conti…
    See more
    • 2w
View 16 more comments
Share quoteSelect how you’d like to share below
Share on Facebook
Share to Twitter
Send in Whatsapp
Share on Linkedin
Privacy  ·  Terms  ·  Cookies  ·  © Meta 2022
Discover fresh voices. Tune into new conversations. Browse all publications